The nominations for 2016 are:
- University of Wollongong
- Dr Maryanne Demasi and ABC-TV Catalyst program on wi-fi
- Professors Alan Bensoussan, Gregory Kolt and Barney Glover at the National Institute of Complementary Medicine, School of Science and Health, Western Sydney University
Nominee: University of Wollongong
Nominated by: Multiple nominations
For approval of a PhD thesis by anti-vaccination campaigner Judy Wilyman, known for an approach to medicine and vaccination that ignores scientific evidence. In the face of criticism, the University has then gone on to defend the notion of freedom of academic opinion (regardless of accuracy) and has effectively washed its hands of the issue and its own responsibility.
Nominee: Dr Maryanne Demasi and ABC-TV Catalyst program on wi-fi
Nominated by: Tim Mendham
For (again) presenting a biased sensationalist story on a scientific topic, in this case non-ionising radiation and the use of wi-fi media. The program had six scare-mongering ‘experts’ ranged against one scientist saying that there wasn’t any scientific evidence that harm was being caused. The story included many unsubstantiated statements that ignored scientific evidence. It confused the proper and normal scientific restraint of saying we can’t be absolutely sure of something; with admitting the something is dangerous. Poor science, bad journalism, overly alarmist, and even the title of the story, ”Wi-Fried”, was sensationalised. Move over Daily Mail, here comes Catalyst.
Nominee: Professors Alan Bensoussan, Gregory Kolt and Barney Glover at the National Institute of Complementary Medicine, School of Science and Health, Western Sydney University
Nominated by: Frank Van der Kooy
For continuing to fully support and defend the use of homeopathy and other unbelievable complementary medicines. For ignoring the detrimental impact that their approach have on science, scientific education and the general health and well-being of the Australian population.
For more information: http://tinyurl.com/zjtwvmm