“Illegal” for health funds to support some ‘natural’ therapies

As part of its overhaul of private health insurance, the Federal government has decided to remove the insurance subsidy from a range of ‘natural’ therapies.

A statement from the Department of Health says that consumers can still choose to access these services, but they will not be able to claim benefits from their insurer.

In fact, it will be illegal for health funds to include the therapies in their coverage, which is generally found in the ‘extras’ package. However, a spokesperson for the Department told Australian Skeptics that funds might end up offering vouchers for such therapies, but they cannot include them in health insurance coverage packages.

The therapies involved are Alexander technique, aromatherapy, Bowen therapy, Buteyko, Feldenkrais, herbalism, homeopathy, iridology, kinesiology, naturopathy, Pilates, reflexology, Rolfing, shiatsu, tai chi, and yoga.

There was some confusion over the fact that Reiki, the energy removal service, was not included in the list, particularly as Health Minister Greg Hunt had mentioned it in press interviews. However, the spokesperson said that that was probably an oversight, and Reiki should have been included.

Chiropractic and acupuncture are not listed among the binned therapies.

The change will take effect from 1 April 2019, and while the government says “[It] will contribute to reducing private health insurance premium price increases,” the amount actually paid out in health benefits for these alt med therapies is only a small component of the billions the funds issue as benefits.

According to a review undertaken some years ago by Australia Skeptics, the amount paid out by health insurance funds in benefits in 2010/11 amounted to $12.4 billion, with the subsidy – the PHI rebate package – valued at around $4.7 billion. This included taxation revenue forgone through exemption of the Medicare levy surcharge, funding the 30 per cent rebate itself, and several hundred million in extra Medicare payments for medical and pharmaceutical services associated with higher private hospital use. Most of the health fund benefits, and thus indirectly the subsidy, went to hospital and general medical treatments.

The “contribution” that this change will make to “reducing premium price increases” may not be that exciting.

The government undertook a review of the rebate on natural therapies for private health insurance in 2015, which found that, overall, there was a paucity of reliable evidence identified for the natural therapies studied.

The findings were not acted upon at the time, however the ALP included dropping the subsidy to natural therapies as part of its policy platform at the last Federal election. Despite some false steps along the way, the government has now decided to bite the bullet and follow suit.

ABC Radio’s Jon Faine interviewed Gerry Dendrinos of the Australian Homeopathic Association over the change; Dendrinos was pleased.

6 thoughts on ““Illegal” for health funds to support some ‘natural’ therapies”

  1. Why would Yoga be an issue? It has scientifically proven benefits and it has helped me immensely with muscle issues and back problems.

  2. Meanwhile the drain on the public healthcare system continues through the gouging of medicare rebates. How about we all take a closer look at how the AMA and NHMRC structure GP visits. Even the skeptics have to see this disparity? Cutting off noses despite faces is what this looks like to me. I think it’s time the government gets out of the “private healthcare” business altogether and the people have the choice in their own healthcare.

    1. Dear Liz,

      The AMA represents no more than 30% of doctors, and the NHMRC is a research funding body. The government, through Medicare sets the structure for the GP visits. In terms of health value these primary care visits are some of the highest on a per cost basis.


  3. You know when you look at the proven studies on the benefits of Reiki/Meditation, its hard to deny it’s not doing any good. The biggest issue in today’s society is that stress is an underlying cause of many health complications. Untreated stress leads to anxiety, depression, panic attacks and in some cases PTSD.. People who attend yoga, meditation and Reiki (I’m sure many other natural therapies also however these I have personally used regularly and had great success with) are taught to use their breathing as a tool to cope with tension, stress and unnecessary worry… teaching people to relax is something they should introduce in schools, workplaces and as a treatment in doctors surgeries prior to prescribing medication! Look at the persons personal life and all aspects to see where improvement/changes can be made to reduce the stress. It amuses me how every time a natural remedy which is proven to to help pops up, Its quick to be knocked down! They are as others have said increasing the need for hospital visits by decreasing the benefits available for treatment which actually bloody works. Medicating people for depression and anxiety only keeps pharmaceutical companies happy, its a mode of possible hope but not a cure. Why not for once Do something in the best interests of the workers… and not those greedy for the dollars 🙄 Skeptical or not, nor one should be disadvantaged for wanting to try non medication options available.

    1. I don’t think many people would doubt the importance of dealing with stress in any medical treatment. And non-medication options are always worth considering, but only if the non-medication options offer benefits that medication can’t offer – and some don’t seem to offer any benefits at all. Reiki would be one of those. Equating Reiki with meditation is a long stretch, as the basis for Reiki is some supposed form of “life force” (qi) which has never been substantiated. The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine is not convinced of any benefit or mechanism for Reiki – https://nccih.nih.gov/health/reiki/introduction.htm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please make sure to read our comments policy before contributing.