A bad day for Sarah

Australian Skeptics Inc’s notorious Bent Spoon award has gone to social media influencer, Sarah’s Day, who promotes questionable natural health remedies via her vast network of followers.

The Bent Spoon, awarded to the proponent of the most preposterous piece of pseudoscientific or paranormal piffle of the year, with past winners including Pete ’Paleo’ Evans, the CSIRO’s head Larry Marshall, the ABC, the Pharmacy Guild of Australia, the University of Wollongong, and a psychic dentist.

Sarah Stevenson, aka Sarah’s Day, picked up the 2018 Bent Spoon for spreading misinformation about health via her online following of over 1 million people, made up largely of young women.

Stevenson has no qualifications in health, but promotes herself as “a holistic health and fitness youtuber” via a Youtube channel, blog and podcast.

On 26 April 2018, Sarah’s Day posted on Instagram “I DID IT!! I reversed my cervical dysplasia”, claiming successful treatment of her pre-cancerous condition through a regimen of “the power of natural medicine, food, lifestyle changes and prayer” and that she “made a conscious effort every day to cure [her] cervix”.

The vast majority of cervical abnormalities are caused by the Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) and the Cancer Council of Australia states that “there is no evidence that there is anything a woman can do in terms of diet and lifestyle that promotes regression”.

“To suggest you can heal your cervix with positive thoughts and green smoothies is not only narcissistic, it’s also dangerous to recommend other women should do the same thing,” said Australian Skeptics Inc. President, Alethea Dean.

“It’s admirable to promote a healthy lifestyle, but believing you’ve healed your cervical dysplasia ‘naturally’ is not grounded in reality.”

A dishonourable mention went to the Therapeutics Goods Administration (TGA) and the Australian Government for enshrining pseudomedical indications in legislation, including, “Balance Aggravated Vanta”, “Upraise/Lift Sunken Middle Qi”, “Moisten Dryness in the Triple Burner” and “Disinhibit water”.

More positive achievements were also noted, with the inaugural Barry Williams Award for Skeptical Journalism going to Jane Hansen, reporter for News Corp, who has written extensively on the anti-vaccination and anti-fluoride movements, fad diets, and quack cures.

The Thornett Award for the Promotion of Reason was given to Dr Ian Musgrave, senior lecturer in pharmacology at the University of Adelaide, who has been a long-standing and effective science communicator in the area of pharmacology and provides a voice of reason in challenging “chem-phobia”.
The winners were announced at the formal dinner on October 13 for the Australian Skeptics’ National Convention, which this year was held in Sydney.

See all of the Bent Spoon nominations here.

5 thoughts on “A bad day for Sarah”

  1. I hope you realise that she has disclaimer in her videos and posts that she is not specialised in these fields, she is simply just sharing what has worked for her personally.

    Clearly your mixing words and making a horrible blog post about someone who doesn’t deserve it. Hate gets ya nowhere budy

    1. Disclaimers do not excuse enthusiastic endorsement of nonsense, particularly for someone with such a large following. – Tim Mendham

    2. Disclaimers don’t excuse putting dangerous misinformation out there. How about I promote drinking bleach but add a disclaimer that it may not work for everyone?

  2. There is no doubt that natural remedies and placebos help the rich and ailing.
    It is also incontrovertible that science trumps natural remedies every time, because they are targeted, dose specific and use pure elements of natural drugs. For example chewing willow bark will alleviate headache, but an aspirin will do it much much better preventing under and overdose.
    Medical and chemical science continually searches natural plants and animals for new drugs not for natural remedies covertable to dose specific medicines for example the poison dart frog could be used for pain relief (200 times more potent than morphine but an effective dose is very close to a lethal dose it also shows some potential as a muscle relaxants, heart stimulants and appetite suppressants. But don’t simply lick one.
    The difference between a deadly poison and a life-saving medicine can be very small; in fact, it is sometimes merely a question of dosage.
    —Dr. R. E. Schultes, 1980
    so I would rather rely on modern medicine and science that naturalist charlatans. Dose specificity and purity …

Leave a Reply to A Sarah's day follower Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please make sure to read our comments policy before contributing.